La Vie est un miracle [2004] Critiques sur CinemaClock

Titre	Vote
12 Angry Men [1957]	10/10
Elephant [2003]	10/10
Pan's Labyrinth [2006]	10/10
Mystic River [2003]	10/10
The Shawshank Redemption [1994]	10/10
Into the Wild [2007]	10/10
Songs From The 2nd Floor [2001]	10/10
Run Lola Run [1999]	10/10
Sunset Boulevard [1950]	9/10
Our Daily Bread [2005]	9/10
Pulp Fiction [1994]	9/10
Requiem for a Dream [2000]	9/10
Shake Hands with the Devil [2007]	9/10
East of Eden [1955]	9/10
Slumdog Millionaire [2008]	9/10
Ce qu'il faut pour vivre [2008]	9/10
Braveheart [1995]	9/10
Chinatown [1974]	9/10
Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow [2004]	9/10
Dark City [1998]	9/10
Lars and the Real Girl [2007]	9/10
Donnie Darko [2001]	9/10
Frost/Nixon [2008]	9/10
Twilight [2008]	9/10
The Red Violin [1998]	9/10
Joyeux Noël [2005]	9/10
Fight Club [1999]	9/10
The Remains Of The Day [1993]	9/10
The Count Of Monte Cristo [2002]	9/10
Rory O'Shea Was Here [2004]	9/10
Amores Perros [2001]	9/10
Mulholland Drive [2001]	9/10
12 Monkeys [1995]	9/10
October Sky [1999]	9/10
Rope [1948]	8/10
Away We Go [2009]	8/10
Riding Alone for Thousands of Miles [2005]	8/10
Talk to Her [2002]	8/10
Lucky Number Slevin [2006]	8/10
Paranoid Park [2007]	8/10
Thank You for Smoking [2005]	8/10
Clandestin [1997]	8/10
The Haunting in Connecticut [2008]	8/10
Last Days [2005]	8/10
Little Children [2006]	8/10
Rec [2007]	8/10
Gran Torino [2008]	8/10
My Life Without Me [2003]	8/10
The Pursuit of Happyness [2006]	8/10
Badlands [1973]	8/10
The Man Who Wasn't There [2001]	8/10
A Walk To Remember [2002]	8/10
Casino [1995]	8/10
Jackie Brown [1997]	8/10
Snatch [2000]	8/10
Inside Man [2006]	8/10
Cube [1997]	8/10
Of Mice and Men [1992]	8/10
The Experiment [2002]	8/10
The Bank Job [2008]	8/10
Saving Private Ryan [1998]	8/10
Lost Highway [1997]	8/10
No Country for Old Men [2007]	8/10
The Insider [1999]	8/10
The Straight Story [1999]	8/10
Sideways [2004]	8/10
Bluff [2007]	8/10
The Wrestler [2008]	8/10
Continental, un film sans fusil [2007]	8/10
Ben X [2007]	8/10
Kinky Boots [2006]	8/10
Taken [2008]	8/10
C'est pas moi, je le jure! [2008]	8/10
The Reader [2008]	8/10
Doubt [2008]	8/10
Yellowknife [2002]	8/10
Stardust [2007]	8/10
Iron Man [2008]	8/10
Felon [2008]	8/10
The Talented Mr. Ripley [1999]	8/10
Ce qu'il reste de nous [2004]	8/10
Fargo [1996]	8/10
Black Hawk Down [2002]	8/10
25th Hour [2002]	8/10
Chocolat [2001]	8/10
Angels in America Vf	8/10
The Road To Perdition [2002]	8/10
Almost Famous [2000]	8/10
The Motorcycle Diaries [2004]	8/10
Les Ordres [1974]	8/10
Les Bons Débarras [1980]	8/10
The Magdalene Sisters [2003]	8/10
Monster [2004]	8/10
Far from Heaven [2002]	8/10
Dreamer: Inspired by a True Story [2005]	7/10
Severance [2006]	7/10
Shakespeare in love [1998]	7/10
Napoleon Dynamite [2004]	7/10
I Love You, Man [2009]	7/10
Eden Lake [2008]	7/10
After Hours [1985]	7/10
National Treasure [2004]	7/10
The Duchess [2008]	7/10
Bridget Jones' Diary [2001]	7/10
Keeping Mum [2005]	7/10
Dédé: À travers les brumes [2009]	7/10
Clue [1985]	7/10
Before the Devil Knows You're Dead [2007]	7/10
Lust, Caution [2007]	7/10
The Guardian [2006]	7/10
The Perfect Storm [2000]	7/10
North Country [2005]	7/10
Snow Cake [2006]	7/10
Flags of Our Fathers [2006]	7/10
Monster's Ball [2002]	7/10
Letters from Iwo Jima [2006]	7/10
The Snow Walker [2003]	7/10
Enemy At The Gates [2001]	7/10
Greenfingers [2001]	7/10
Down By Law [1986]	7/10
45 R.P.M. [2008]	7/10
Knowing [2009]	7/10
The Emperor's Club [2002]	7/10
Mamma Mia! [2008]	7/10
Signs [2002]	7/10
Donnie Brasco [1997]	7/10
Catch Me If You Can [2002]	7/10
Milk [2008]	7/10
Eastern Promises [2007]	7/10
Valkyrie [2008]	7/10
Michael Clayton [2007]	7/10
The Usual Suspects [1995]	7/10
Sleepers [1996]	7/10
Le Survenant [2005]	7/10
Flyboys [2006]	7/10
Atonement [2007]	7/10
The Station Agent [2003]	7/10
Cider House Rules [1999]	7/10
Le Nèg' [2002]	7/10
Rachel Getting Married [2008]	7/10
Ripley's Game [2002]	7/10
The Bucket List [2008]	7/10
Death of a President [2006]	7/10
Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist [2008]	7/10
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button [2008]	7/10
Penelope [2006]	7/10
Carlito's Way [1993]	7/10
Changeling [2008]	7/10
Funny Games [2008]	7/10
Le Pacte Des Loups [2001]	7/10
Hellboy 2: The Golden Army [2008]	7/10
In Bruges [2008]	7/10
Last Night [1998]	7/10
National Treasure: Book of Secrets [2007]	7/10
The Orphanage [2007]	7/10
Mean Girls [2004]	7/10
Boogie Nights [1997]	7/10
The French Connection [1971]	7/10
Amazing Grace [2006]	7/10
The Last of the Mohicans [1992]	7/10
Memento [2001]	7/10
Poseidon [2006]	7/10
Jumper [2008]	7/10
The Spiderwick Chronicles [2008]	7/10
Miami Vice [2006]	7/10
Fracture [2007]	7/10
The Sweet Hereafter [1997]	7/10
Closer [2004]	7/10
Hot Fuzz [2007]	7/10
Prom Queen	7/10
Adaptation [2002]	7/10
Lost in Translation [2003]	7/10
The Heartbreak Kid [2007]	7/10
L.A. Confidential [1997]	7/10
Brick [2006]	7/10
Family Plot [1976]	6/10
Seabiscuit [2003]	6/10
Shine [1996]	6/10
Mémoires affectives [2004]	6/10
The Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian [2008]	6/10
Sunshine Cleaning [2009]	6/10
Adventureland [2009]	6/10
Paris, Texas [1984]	6/10
From Dusk Till Dawn [1996]	6/10
We Were Soldiers [2002]	6/10
Polytechnique v.f. [2009]	6/10
Defiance [2009]	6/10
Derailed [2005]	6/10
Congorama [2006]	6/10
Frida [2002]	6/10
The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford [2007]	6/10
Oliver Twist [2005]	6/10
THX 1138 [1971]	6/10
Que Dieu bénisse l'Amérique [2006]	6/10
Unbreakable [2000]	6/10
The People vs. Larry Flynt [1996]	6/10
Infernal Affairs [2002]	6/10
The Edukators [2004]	6/10
Forgetting Sarah Marshall [2008]	6/10
Two Lovers [2008]	6/10
Coraline [2009]	6/10
Burn After Reading [2008]	6/10
I Now Pronounce You Chuck and Larry [2007]	6/10
Swingers [1996]	6/10
Fido [2006]	6/10
Bienvenue chez les Ch'tis [2008]	6/10
Amnésie - L'Énigme James Brighton [2005]	6/10
21 [2008]	6/10
Enchanted [2007]	6/10
Role Models [2008]	6/10
Dancer In The Dark [2000]	6/10
Shaun of the Dead [2004]	6/10
Collateral [2004]	6/10
Pay It Forward [2000]	6/10
About Adam [2001]	6/10
Silk [2007]	6/10
Sex and the City [2008]	6/10
Wonder Boys [2000]	6/10
La Ligne brisée [2008]	6/10
Armageddon [1998]	6/10
Blue Velvet [1986]	6/10
There Will Be Blood [2007]	6/10
Children of Men [2006]	6/10
Vera Drake [2004]	6/10
Big Chill [1983]	6/10
Wimbledon [2004]	6/10
Twin Peaks Fire Walk With Me [1992]	6/10
Superbad [2007]	6/10
Volver [2006]	6/10
Broken Flowers [2005]	6/10
The Others [2001]	6/10
The Legend of 1900 [1998]	6/10
Kingdom of Heaven [2005]	5/10
Let's Go to Prison [2006]	5/10
Miracle [2004]	5/10
V for Vendetta [2006]	5/10
Life is a Miracle [2004]	5/10
Miller's Crossing [1990]	5/10
La Cité des enfants perdus [1999]	5/10
Snow Falling On Cedars [1999]	5/10
Battle in Seattle [2007]	5/10
Race to Witch Mountain [2009]	5/10
Beerfest [2006]	5/10
August Rush [2007]	5/10
The Shipping News [2001]	5/10
La Promesse [1996]	5/10
The Edge of Heaven [2007]	5/10
Philadelphia [1993]	5/10
Heavenly Creatures [1994]	5/10
Revolutionary Road [2009]	5/10
About a Boy [2002]	5/10
Juno [2007]	5/10
Charlie Bartlett [2007]	5/10
Tropic Thunder [2008]	5/10
A Mighty Heart [2007]	5/10
Gone Baby Gone [2007]	5/10
House of Sand and Fog [2003]	5/10
Chouchou [2002]	5/10
Never Been Kissed [1999]	5/10
Bedtime Stories [2008]	5/10
Ma tante Aline [2007]	5/10
The Love Guru [2008]	5/10
The Woodsman [2004]	5/10
Goodfellas [1990]	5/10
Dreamgirls [2006]	5/10
Zodiac [2007]	5/10
The Stepford Wives [2004]	5/10
After The Wedding [2007]	5/10
The Fountain [2006]	5/10
Gangs of New York [2002]	4/10
Mrs. Henderson Presents [2005]	4/10
Harrison's Flowers [2002]	4/10
Owning Mahowny [2003]	4/10
Saints-Martyrs-des-Damnés [2005]	4/10
The Visitor [2007]	4/10
La Brunante [2006]	4/10
Histoire de famille [2006]	4/10
De battre mon coeur s'est arrêté [2005]	4/10
4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days [2007]	4/10
Vicky Cristina Barcelona [2008]	4/10
Push [2009]	4/10
Clerks II [2006]	4/10
Inkheart [2007]	4/10
Hearts in Atlantis [2001]	4/10
In the Valley of Elah [2007]	4/10
Hairspray [2007]	4/10
Beyond the Sea [2004]	4/10
Office Space [1999]	4/10
The Invasion [2007]	4/10
Sunshine [2007]	4/10
Babine [2008]	4/10
Accepted [2006]	4/10
She's the Man [2006]	4/10
Lakeview Terrace [2008]	4/10
Godsend [2004]	4/10
The Order [2003]	4/10
Babylon A.D. [2008]	4/10
Two for the Money [2005]	4/10
Grace Is Gone [2007]	4/10
I Am Sam [2002]	4/10
My Own Private Idaho [1991]	4/10
Hard Candy [2006]	4/10
Stranger Than Fiction [2006]	4/10
Jarhead [2005]	3/10
La Vie avec mon père [2005]	3/10
Dinner Rush	3/10
Harold and Kumar Go to White Castle [2004]	3/10
Marie Antoinette [2006]	3/10
Resurrecting the Champ [2007]	3/10
La Doublure [2006]	3/10
Un Été sans point ni coup sûr [2008]	3/10
Before Sunrise [1995]	3/10
He's Just Not That Into You [2008]	3/10
Unforgiven [1992]	3/10
Maman Last Call [2005]	3/10
Employee of the Month [2006]	3/10
Cloverfield [2008]	3/10
A Lot Like Love [2005]	3/10
R.V. [2006]	3/10
My Super Ex-Girlfriend [2006]	3/10
Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day [2008]	3/10
The Happening [2008]	3/10
Love Song For Bobby Long	3/10
Venus [2006]	2/10
P.S. I Love You [2007]	2/10
Bride Wars [2009]	1/10
1408 [2007]	1/10
Bewitched [2005]	1/10
Confessions of a Shopaholic [2008]	1/10
Monica la Mitraille [2004]	1/10
Brice de Nice [2004]	1/10
A Cinderella Story [2004]	1/10
13 Going on 30 [2004]	1/10
Un Crabe dans la tête [2001]	1/10
Spanglish [2004]	1/10
Stardom [2000]	1/10
Lovers On The Bridge (French / Eng. Sub.)	1/10

Il n'est pas évident la première heure de se retrouver dans cette histoire qui a l'air d'aller nulle part, peuplée d'animaux en folie et minée par les explosifs de la guerre en Bosnie illustrée par un carousel d'images sulvoltées noyées sous un flot de musique gitane, mais derrière une apparente bonhomie naïve et un air d'improvisation feinte se révèle une réalisation maîtrisée de bout en bout, portée par un souffle puissant et un grand rire dévastateur par quoi on se laisse peu à peu emporter, pour se retrouver à la fin ravi et réconcilié avec la vie, ses contradictions et ses absurdités.

C'était étrange quand l'écran s'est éteint pour laisser place aux génériques finaux. Mon esprit passait en révision les stupidités des êtres bons et pas bons et s'en étonnait, alors que mon coeur était en quelque sorte bercé, enchanté... Bizzare!. Je n'ai pas pu donner une note immédiatement. Aujourd'hui, un mois plus tard, j'ai revu la pochette du film et j'ai l'impression d'avoir vu l'auteur étreindre affectueusement tout ce village-là, tous ces gens, tous les animaux. Comme le regard tendre d'une grande-maman bien dans sa peau. Le film est loufoque, absurde et tendre. Et j'en ai un «souvenir» très agréable. Je le reverrai, ce film.