Polytechnique v.f. [2009] Critiques sur CinemaClock

Profondément troublant... Impossible de rester insensible tant la mise en scène, magnifique, de Denis Villeneuve vient nous chercher. La photographie en noir et blanc est superbe. Et le jeu des comédiens très vrais. Un film sur la haine parfois incontrôlable de l'être humain. Le film de Villeneuve est plus qu'un témoignage de l'horreur vécu par ces étudiants il y a 20 ans. Le film est un hommage, et aussi un message d'espoir pour cette vie qui semble parfois trop difficile. J'espère vraiment que les gens cesseront de dire que ce film n'a été fait que pour faire de l'argent. Pour les proches des victimes de cette affreuse tuerie, ce film demeurera une fenêtre sur la vie de leurs chers disparus.

Titre	Vote
Lorenzo's Oil	10/10
Ponette [1996]	10/10
There Will Be Blood [2007]	10/10
The Dark Crystal [1982]	10/10
The Reflecting Skin [1990]	10/10
Bagdad Cafe [1988]	10/10
Slumdog Millionaire [2008]	10/10
The Duchess [2008]	10/10
Poltergeist [1982]	10/10
The Dark Knight [2008]	10/10
Aliens [1986]	10/10
Empire of the Sun [1987]	10/10
Into the Wild [2007]	10/10
The Breakfast Club [1985]	10/10
La Vie en rose [2007]	10/10
Howl's Moving Castle [2004]	10/10
The Orphanage [2007]	10/10
Color Purple [1985]	10/10
Alien [1979]	10/10
300 [2007]	10/10
The Shawshank Redemption [1994]	10/10
Le Renard et L'Enfant [2007]	9/10
The Fall [2006]	9/10
Ladyhawke	9/10
The Neverending Story [1984]	9/10
Boy A [2007]	9/10
The Unknown Woman [2006]	9/10
Séraphine [2008]	9/10
Dragonslayer [1981]	9/10
The Secret of NIMH [1982]	9/10
Sorcerer	9/10
Legend [1985]	9/10
Muriel's Wedding [1994]	9/10
C'est pas moi, je le jure! [2008]	9/10
Polytechnique v.f. [2009]	9/10
The Reader [2008]	9/10
Waitress [2007]	9/10
Four Minutes [2006]	9/10
Rec [2007]	9/10
Tout est parfait [2008]	9/10
Wall-E [2008]	9/10
À l'intérieur [2007]	9/10
Funny Games [2008]	9/10
The Devil's Backbone [2002]	9/10
Ben X [2007]	9/10
Dolores Claiborne [1995]	9/10
No Country for Old Men [2007]	9/10
The Changeling [1980]	9/10
Atonement [2007]	9/10
Juno [2007]	9/10
Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street [2007]	9/10
Across the Universe [2007]	9/10
The Kite Runner [2007]	9/10
The Mist [2007]	9/10
8 femmes [2002]	9/10
The Abyss [1989]	9/10
28 Weeks Later... [2007]	9/10
Bug [2006]	9/10
Son of Rambow [2007]	8/10
Midnight Meat Train [2008]	8/10
Julie & Julia [2009]	8/10
Terminator Salvation [2009]	8/10
Martyrs [2008]	8/10
The Girl with the Dragon Tatto [2009]	8/10
My Sister's Keeper [2009]	8/10
The Children	8/10
Trick 'r Treat [2008]	8/10
Australia [2008]	8/10
Bright Star [2009]	8/10
De père en flic [2009]	8/10
Entre les murs [2008]	8/10
Let the Right One In [2008]	8/10
A Tree of Palme	8/10
Cold Prey	8/10
Blindness [2008]	8/10
Always (1989)	8/10
Radio Flyer [1992]	8/10
Ice Age 3: Dawn of the Dinosaurs [2009]	8/10
Anguish	8/10
Peggy Sue Got Married [1986]	8/10
Heathers [1989]	8/10
Jack The Bear	8/10
Up [2009]	8/10
Blue Car [2003]	8/10
Angel [2007]	8/10
Frozen River [2008]	8/10
Red [2008]	8/10
Faubourg 36 [2008]	8/10
Contre toute espérance [2007]	8/10
Star Trek [2009]	8/10
The Boy in the Striped Pajamas [2008]	8/10
La Premier jour du reste de ta vie [2008]	8/10
Away from Her [2006]	8/10
Live and Become [2005]	8/10
Paloma Delight [2007]	8/10
Changeling [2008]	8/10
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button [2008]	8/10
Doubt [2008]	8/10
Babine [2008]	8/10
Nim's Island [2008]	8/10
Lars and the Real Girl [2007]	8/10
Kung Fu Panda [2008]	8/10
On a Clear Day [2006]	8/10
Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day [2008]	8/10
Kinky Boots [2006]	8/10
Death Sentence [2007]	8/10
Ghost Town [2008]	8/10
Closure - Vengeance à Froid (Biling.)	8/10
Wind Chill [2007]	8/10
An American Haunting [2005]	8/10
Rogue [2006]	8/10
Fido [2006]	8/10
The X-Files: I Want to Believe [2008]	8/10
Hellboy 2: The Golden Army [2008]	8/10
Wanted [2008]	8/10
Dans les villes [2006]	8/10
P.S. I Love You [2007]	8/10
Freedom Writers [2007]	8/10
Alien 3 [1992]	8/10
Spiral [2007]	8/10
Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull [2008]	8/10
30 Days of Night [2007]	8/10
La Brunante [2006]	8/10
Cujo (25th Anniversary Edition)	8/10
The Woods [2006]	8/10
Ils [2006]	8/10
Lady in White (Widescreen)	8/10
Right at Your Door [2006]	8/10
Cloverfield [2008]	8/10
Beowulf [2007]	8/10
Rescue Dawn [2006]	8/10
Elizabeth: The Golden Age [2007]	8/10
The Abandoned [2006]	8/10
Agnes Of God [1985]	8/10
Sunshine [2007]	8/10
Hairspray [2007]	8/10
The Brave One [2007]	8/10
The Girl in the Park [2007]	7/10
The Twilight Saga: New Moon [2009]	7/10
Les Pieds dans le vide [2008]	7/10
Ninja Assassin [2009]	7/10
A Christmas Carol [2009]	7/10
Dead Snow [2009]	7/10
Le Code a changé [2009]	7/10
5150 rue des Ormes [2009]	7/10
The Thief Lord	7/10
Deadgirl [2008]	7/10
Cliente [2009]	7/10
Wonderful Days [2003]	7/10
Pandorum [2009]	7/10
Zombieland [2009]	7/10
The Surrogates [2009]	7/10
Battle for Terra [2007]	7/10
9 [2009]	7/10
Fighting [2009]	7/10
The Bucket List [2008]	7/10
Wolfhound	7/10
Splinter [2008]	7/10
A Perfect Getaway [2009]	7/10
Storm (2005)	7/10
Le Nouveau Protocole	7/10
Dante 01	7/10
The Burrowers [2008]	7/10
Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince [2009]	7/10
3:10 to Yuma [2007]	7/10
The Tale of Despereaux [2008]	7/10
Voyages [1999]	7/10
Happy-Go-Lucky [2008]	7/10
Dead Of Winter	7/10
Outlander [2008]	7/10
Angels & Demons [2009]	7/10
Dance of the Dead [2008]	7/10
Before the Rains [2007]	7/10
Henry Poole Is Here [2008]	7/10
Continental, un film sans fusil [2007]	7/10
Ma fille mon ange [2006]	7/10
Loverboy (2005)	7/10
Knowing [2009]	7/10
Rails & Ties [2007]	7/10
Vicky Cristina Barcelona [2008]	7/10
Un Fil à la patte [2005]	7/10
Forgetting Sarah Marshall [2008]	7/10
Then She Found Me [2007]	7/10
Un Été sans point ni coup sûr [2008]	7/10
End of The Line	7/10
Quarantine [2008]	7/10
Eagle Eye [2008]	7/10
The Devil's Chair	7/10
Snow Angels [2007]	7/10
La Capture v.f. [2006]	7/10
CJ7 [2008]	7/10
The Life Before Her Eyes [2007]	7/10
Death Race [2008]	7/10
Doomsday [2008]	7/10
Invasion (2005)	7/10
Jack Brooks: Monster Slayer [2007]	7/10
Never Back Down [2008]	7/10
Teeth [2007]	7/10
Silk	7/10
The Bank Job [2008]	7/10
Hancock [2008]	7/10
The Golden Door [2006]	7/10
The Incredible Hulk [2008]	7/10
The Strangers [2007]	7/10
Danika	7/10
Borderland [2007]	7/10
Iron Man [2008]	7/10
Believers (Unrated, New Pack)	7/10
Automaton Transfusion [2008]	7/10
The Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian [2008]	7/10
The Ruins [2008]	7/10
Southern Comfort (1981)	7/10
Pulse [2001]	7/10
Dog Soldiers [2002]	7/10
The Eye [2007]	7/10
Joshua [2007]	7/10
The Reaping [2006]	7/10
Altered [2006]	7/10
1408 [2007]	7/10
The Secret of Moonacre [2009]	6/10
Law Abiding Citizen [2009]	6/10
The Thaw	6/10
2012 [2009]	6/10
Delgo [2008]	6/10
Guerre Des Miss	6/10
Boy Eats Girl	6/10
Push [2009]	6/10
Dark Matter [2007]	6/10
Howard The Duck	6/10
Inkheart [2007]	6/10
Taken [2008]	6/10
Twilight [2008]	6/10
X-Men Origins: Wolverine [2009]	6/10
Race to Witch Mountain [2009]	6/10
Harold [2008]	6/10
Cruising Bar 2 [2008]	6/10
The Marsh [2006]	6/10
Timber Falls [2007]	6/10
Contre-enquête [2007]	6/10
Anamorph [2007]	6/10
Color of the Cross [2006]	6/10
Mirrors [2008]	6/10
Days Of Darkness	6/10
The Lazarus Child [2004]	6/10
Victim (2006)	6/10
The Happening [2008]	6/10
Mulberry Street [2006]	6/10
Pulse [2006]	6/10
Solstice	6/10
The Invisible [2007]	6/10
Aliens vs. Predator: Requiem [2007]	6/10
P2 [2007]	6/10
Evening [2007]	6/10
Resident Evil: Extinction [2007]	6/10
7eventy 5ive [2007]	5/10
G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra [2009]	5/10
Crusade: A March Through Time	5/10
Space Chimps [2008]	5/10
Joy Ride 2: Dead Ahead	5/10
Kaw	5/10
10,000 B.C. [2008]	5/10
It Waits	5/10
Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen [2009]	4/10
Never Cry Werewolf	4/10
The Vanguard [2008]	4/10
Simon Says [2006]	3/10
La Belle bête [2006]	3/10
Big Bad Wolf	2/10
Socket	2/10
D-War [2007]	2/10
Grizzly Park [2008]	1/10