Magnolia [1999] Critiques sur CinemaClock

"Magnolia" est plutôt déroutant pour un film américain et le moins que l'on puisse dire c'est qu'il laisse songeur quant aux métaphores qui y sont présentées. J'ai vu le film il y a trois jours à peine et ce matin... qu'elle surprise de constater que ce film soit en nomination dans la catégorie "scénario - originalité"!!! En fait, non, c'est une demie surprise car en effet, bien qu'il y ait des événements prévisibles, impossible de prédire ce qui peut bien nous tomber sur la tête!!! Pour ce qui est de la trame sonore, entièrement d'accord pour que ce film soit en nomination dans cette catégorie. Malheureusement, à mon avis, ce film est un peu trop long... mais il ne mérite certainement pas "1" ou "2" mais quelque chose comme "7" ou "8". Voilà c'est fait, 8 /10.

Titre	Vote
The Shawshank Redemption [1994]	10/10
Forrest Gump [1994]	10/10
The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King [2003]	10/10
The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers [2002]	10/10
The Lord Of The Rings: The Fellowship Of The Ring [2001]	10/10
Dancer In The Dark [2000]	10/10
The Prestige [2006]	9/10
Pulp Fiction [1994]	9/10
Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince [2009]	9/10
Les Invincibles [TV]	9/10
Back to the Future [1985]	9/10
Shrek [2001]	9/10
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets [2002]	9/10
C.R.A.Z.Y. [2005]	9/10
Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone [2001]	9/10
The French Connection [1971]	9/10
The Bourne Ultimatum [2007]	9/10
Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire [2005]	9/10
Le Fabuleux destin d'Amélie Poulain [2001]	9/10
Chocolat [2001]	9/10
Cider House Rules [1999]	9/10
Valkyrie [2008]	8/10
17 Again [2009]	8/10
Layer Cake [2004]	8/10
Twilight [2008]	8/10
300 [2007]	8/10
Mission: Impossible 3 [2006]	8/10
The Ugly Truth [2009]	8/10
De père en flic [2009]	8/10
GoldenEye [1995]	8/10
GoldenEye [1995]	8/10
The Bourne Supremacy [2004]	8/10
Back to the Future Part III [1990]	8/10
Babine [2008]	8/10
Beyond Borders [2003]	8/10
American Gangster [2007]	8/10
Australia [2008]	8/10
Bienvenue chez les Ch'tis [2008]	8/10
King Kong [2005]	8/10
Big Fish [2003]	8/10
Magnolia [1999]	8/10
Titanic [1997]	8/10
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button [2008]	8/10
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix [2007]	8/10
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban [2004]	8/10
Shrek the Halls [2007]	8/10
Shrek the Third [2007]	8/10
Shrek 2 [2004]	8/10
Beowulf [2007]	8/10
The Great Debaters [2007]	8/10
Astérix et Obélix: Mission Cléopâtre [2002]	8/10
Pay It Forward [2000]	8/10
Training Day [2001]	8/10
Die Another Day [2002]	8/10
Iron Man [2008]	8/10
The Golden Compass [2007]	8/10
Elizabeth: The Golden Age [2007]	8/10
1408 [2007]	8/10
Cinderella Man [2005]	8/10
XXX [2002]	8/10
Jimmy Neutron: Boy Genius [2001]	8/10
Ocean's Eleven [2001]	8/10
Spy Game [2001]	8/10
K-Pax [2001]	8/10
Hearts in Atlantis [2001]	8/10
Legally Blonde 1 [2001]	8/10
Rush Hour 2 [2001]	8/10
The Princess Diaries [2001]	8/10
Pearl Harbor [2001]	8/10
Nuit De Noces [2001]	8/10
Le Placard [2001]	8/10
One Night At McCool's [2001]	8/10
Family Man [2000]	8/10
Meet The Parents [2000]	8/10
The Legend Of Bagger Vance [2000]	8/10
Almost Famous [2000]	8/10
Taxi 2 [2000]	8/10
Remember The Titans [2000]	8/10
Gladiator [2000]	8/10
Erin Brockovich [2000]	8/10
Imax: Cosmic Voyage [1996]	7/10
Imax: Blue Planet [1990]	7/10
Corpse Bride [2005]	7/10
Imax: Space Station [2002]	7/10
Imax: L5: First City in Space	7/10
Matchstick Men [2003]	7/10
My Cousin Vinny	7/10
Mr. Brooks [2007]	7/10
Scent of a Woman [1992]	7/10
Lean On Me	7/10
Elvis Gratton: Le King de Kings [1985]	7/10
Frida [2002]	7/10
Fracture [2007]	7/10
Secret de banlieue [2002]	7/10
Ghost [1990]	7/10
Underworld [2003]	7/10
Duplex [2003]	7/10
The Transporter 2 [2005]	7/10
Saint-Jacques... La Mecque [2005]	7/10
1981 [2009]	7/10
U-571 [2000]	7/10
Mission: Impossible [1996]	7/10
W. [2008]	7/10
Les Doigts croches [2009]	7/10
The World Is Not Enough [1999]	7/10
K-19: The Widowmaker [2002]	7/10
Apocalypto [2006]	7/10
The Reader [2008]	7/10
Marley & Me [2008]	7/10
Nitro [2007]	7/10
The Simpsons Movie [2007]	7/10
Boys Don't Cry [1999]	7/10
Much Ado About Nothing [1993]	7/10
Les 3 p'tits cochons [2007]	7/10
The Island [2005]	7/10
Maurice Richard [2005]	7/10
Bruce Almighty [2003]	7/10
Dans une galaxie près de chez vous 2 [2008]	7/10
Yes Man [2008]	7/10
Liar Liar [1997]	7/10
True Lies	7/10
Le Grand départ [2008]	7/10
Le Secret de ma mère [2006]	7/10
Garfield: The Movie [2004]	7/10
Maman Last Call [2005]	7/10
La Vie après l'amour [2000]	7/10
The Big One [1997]	7/10
Les Boys 3 [2001]	7/10
Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull [2008]	7/10
The Bank Job [2008]	7/10
French Connection 1 & 2	7/10
Untraceable [2008]	7/10
Journey to the Center of the Earth [2008]	7/10
Sex and the City [2008]	7/10
National Treasure: Book of Secrets [2007]	7/10
Cruising Bar 2 [2008]	7/10
Black Hawk Down [2002]	7/10
Ocean's Thirteen [2007]	7/10
Resident Evil: Apocalypse [2004]	7/10
Resident Evil: Extinction [2007]	7/10
Resident Evil [2002]	7/10
The Quick And The Dead [1995]	7/10
The Last Legion [2007]	7/10
Fantastic Four [2005]	7/10
Pitch Black [2000]	7/10
We Were Soldiers [2002]	7/10
Ali [2001]	7/10
A Beautiful Mind [2001]	7/10
Vanilla Sky [2001]	7/10
Kate And Leopold [2001]	7/10
Riding In Cars With Boys [2001]	7/10
American Pie 1 [1999]	7/10
American Pie 2 [2001]	7/10
Rush Hour [1998]	7/10
A.I.: Artificial Intelligence [2001]	7/10
A Knight's Tale [2001]	7/10
Spy Kids 1 [2001]	7/10
Bridget Jones' Diary [2001]	7/10
Traffic [2001]	7/10
Head Over Heels [2001]	7/10
Finding Forrester [2000]	7/10
Miss Congeniality [2000]	7/10
What Women Want [2000]	7/10
Proof Of Life [2000]	7/10
Bait [2000]	7/10
Space Cowboys [2000]	7/10
The Bachelor [1999]	7/10
Mission: Impossible 2 [2000]	7/10
28 Days [2000]	7/10
Wrongfully Accused [1998]	7/10
The Witches of Eastwick [1987]	6/10
Identity [2003]	6/10
Mr. & Mrs. Smith [2005]	6/10
Miss Congeniality 2: Armed and Fabulous [2005]	6/10
Les Voleurs d'enfance [2005]	6/10
Jailhouse Rock [1957]	6/10
Cellular [2004]	6/10
The Surrogates [2009]	6/10
La Turbulence des fluides [2002]	6/10
Auto Focus [2002]	6/10
Little Man [2006]	6/10
La Soupe Aux Choux	6/10
Post Grad [2009]	6/10
Les Grandes chaleurs [2009]	6/10
Les Pieds dans le vide [2008]	6/10
The Time Traveler's Wife [2008]	6/10
The Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian [2008]	6/10
The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe [2005]	6/10
16 Blocks [2006]	6/10
Then She Found Me [2007]	6/10
Un Été sans point ni coup sûr [2008]	6/10
Nouvelle France [2004]	6/10
The Road To Perdition [2002]	6/10
The Pink Panther [2006]	6/10
Jumper [2008]	6/10
The Hulk [2003]	6/10
War of the Worlds [2005]	6/10
Notes on a Scandal [2006]	6/10
Astérix aux jeux olympiques [2008]	6/10
Forgetting Sarah Marshall [2008]	6/10
The Shadow	6/10
Lars and the Real Girl [2007]	6/10
Guide de la petite vengeance [2006]	6/10
The Black Dahlia [2006]	6/10
Mission To Mars [2000]	6/10
Shallow Hal [2001]	6/10
Planet Of The Apes [2001]	6/10
Jurassic Park 3 [2001]	6/10
The Mexican [2001]	6/10
Cast Away [2000]	6/10
Unbreakable [2000]	6/10
Nurse Betty [2000]	6/10
The Replacements [2000]	6/10
What Lies Beneath [2000]	6/10
The Whole Nine Yards [2000]	6/10
Gothika [2003]	5/10
You've Got Mail [1998]	5/10
Van Helsing [2004]	5/10
The Core [2003]	5/10
Kindergarten Cop	5/10
Big Momma's House [2000]	5/10
Bulletproof Monk [2002]	5/10
New York Minute [2004]	5/10
Head of State [2003]	5/10
Alex and Emma [2003]	5/10
Showgirls [1995]	5/10
Swordfish [2001]	5/10
Are We Done Yet? [2007]	5/10
Mystery Men [1999]	5/10
The Hoax [2006]	5/10
Twins [1988]	5/10
Desperate Measures [1998]	5/10
Crank [2006]	5/10
Inkheart [2007]	5/10
Quantum of Solace [2008]	5/10
Fargo [1996]	5/10
Baraka [1992]	5/10
My Best Friend's Girl [2008]	5/10
Premier Juillet: le film [2004]	5/10
Good Night, and Good Luck. [2005]	5/10
Super Size Me [2004]	5/10
2046 [2004]	5/10
Supernova [2000]	5/10
Red Planet [2000]	5/10
Serendipity [2001]	5/10
Sweet November [2001]	5/10
The Wedding Planner [2001]	5/10
The Patriot [2000]	5/10
The Flintstones In Viva Rock Vegas [2000]	5/10
DOA: Dead or Alive [2006]	4/10
Firewall [2006]	4/10
Lake Placid [1999]	4/10
The Truth About Charlie [2002]	4/10
Elvis Gratton II: Miracle à Memphis [1999]	4/10
Bulletproof [1996]	4/10
Open Water [2003]	4/10
Josie And The Pussycats [2001]	4/10
The Break-Up [2006]	4/10
Dude, Where's My Car? [2000]	4/10
All About Steve [2008]	4/10
Borat [2006]	4/10
Brainstorm	4/10
The Other Boleyn Girl [2007]	4/10
The Hunted [2003]	4/10
The Bridge of San Luis Rey [2004]	4/10
Elvis Gratton XXX: La Vengeance d'Elvis Wong [2004]	3/10
Vendus [2004]	3/10
Divine Secrets of the Ya-Ya Sisterhood [2002]	3/10
District 9 [2009]	3/10
The Prince & Me [2004]	3/10
School of Rock [2003]	3/10
Le Projet: Mindstorm	3/10
OSS 117: Rio ne répond plus [2009]	2/10
Bad Girls (Extended Version)	2/10
Grind [2003]	2/10
Gray Matters [2006]	2/10
Dr. T And The Women [2000]	2/10
The Ex [2007]	2/10
Brice de Nice [2004]	2/10
In the Name of the King: A Dungeon Siege Tale [2008]	2/10
15 Minutes [2000]	2/10
Fear Dot Com [2002]	1/10