I Can

A young couple's adulterous affair results in pregnancy, leading them to abandon their spouses and start life together. Their daughter Katelyn is born with only one fully formed arm, prompting parents Eric and Salena to turn their lives over to God. Eric sees her deformity as judgment on their sin and lives fearing the next tragedy. Katelyn grows into a star high school center fielder with an I CAN mentality, overcoming her disability to reach for an NCAA scholarship. A serious injury then forces Katelyn to wrestle with God's plan and Eric with the demons of his past.